What a set-topic contest is
In an ordinary scholarship essay, you answer a question about yourself. In a contest with a set topic, every entry answers the same assigned question, and the judges compare how well each writer handled it. The Prompt Bank holds several, including the VFW, Optimist International, the Elie Wiesel Foundation, Stossel in the Classroom, the DAR and the American Legion Auxiliary. Four of their prompts:
What a Veteran Taught Me About America.
“Finding My Voice in a World Full of Noise”
Most of us are never asked to be heroes. But, at some point, nearly all of us face a smaller and harder question: Do I go along with this, or do I refuse? Does our responsibility change depending on the scope of the question? Explain the moral standard behind your decision, then confront the strongest objection to it.
What are the purposes of executive orders and emergency powers? Explain the constitutional basis of executive orders and emergency powers and whether their recent increased use by presidents of both parties has been an abuse of executive power. In your entry, choose one specific use of executive power — a particular executive order or emergency declaration. Explore what action the president took, what legal or constitutional authority was used to justify it, and how other branches responded. Then take and support a position on whether that use was an abuse of executive power.
The VFW offers Patriot's Pen at 300 to 400 words and Voice of Democracy as an audio essay, both with the same theme. The Optimist essay goes through the local Optimist Club. Elie Wiesel allows up to 3,500 words. Stossel's four prompts allow 500 to 1,000 words.
Read the rules before the topic
Contests list rules that other scholarships do not. Elie Wiesel requires English, a title, double spacing, 12-point type, and numbered pages, and judges anonymously, so you cannot put your name, school or other identifying references on the essay or title page. Gravity Research Foundation caps an entry at 10 pages. The American Legion Auxiliary asks for a cover sheet and says the essay must be the work of one individual.
Make a one-line checklist from the rules page before you write a word. Disqualification for format hurts more than a weak paragraph.
Research from named sources
A topic question that asks about law, history or ethics needs facts. Use sources you can name: a government site, a court document, a book, a published study, a newspaper article with a date.
- Write the question in your own words.
- List three things you must be able to prove.
- Find a source for each. Take notes with the title, author, date and page.
- Look for one strong point on the other side. The Elie Wiesel prompt asks you to confront the strongest opposing argument, so a one-sided essay misses part of the question.
Stay with a narrow case. The Stossel prompt asks you to choose one specific use of executive power, so a single well-explained example beats a survey of ten.
Citing
Check what the contest wants. Stossel says to cite your sources and lets a Works Cited list count toward the 500-word minimum. The DAR contest judges the quality and scope of references, in particular the use of primary sources (original letters, records, documents from the time). The University of Arkansas says to cite sources when you use published or web-based information. OSAC tells you not to include URLs when citing.
Pick one style, such as MLA or APA, and use it everywhere. When the contest names a style, use that one. A short, correct list of 4 to 6 real sources reads better than a long list you did not use.
How judging works
Read what the rules say judges score. The DAR contest names historical accuracy, organization of materials, interest, originality, spelling, grammar, punctuation, and the quality and scope of references. That list is a rubric you can write to.
A judge reads many entries on the same topic. The ones that hold up give a clear answer to the exact question and evidence the reader can check. Put your answer in the first paragraph. Support it in the middle. Say what follows from it at the end.
For a general view of scoring, see how scholarship essays are judged.
Some contests do not accept AI
The Stossel contest says plagiarized or AI-generated content will be disqualified. The American Legion Auxiliary says essays checked and found to be 30 percent or more AI written are disqualified. See the AI rules providers publish.
Questions this page answers
- Can I reuse a contest essay for another scholarship?
Rarely. A set-topic essay answers one assigned question, so it only fits another prompt after heavy rewriting.
- Do I need a title?
Elie Wiesel requires one. Where the rules are silent, a short plain title is fine and costs few words.
- Where do I submit?
The VFW and Optimist contests go through a local post or club. Read the rules page for the address.