# How scholarship essays are judged, in the providers' words

Providers that publish judging lines name a short list: answering the topic, original thought, organization, clarity, grammar and, sometimes, creativity. The American Legion Auxiliary scores 25 points for the topic and 25 for original thought out of 100. Anonymous judging and interviews appear at a few providers.

Last reviewed: Nov. 18, 2026

## The American Legion Auxiliary publishes a point rubric


This is the most exact judging line in the bank. The [American Legion Auxiliary Americanism Essay Contest](https://www.alaforveterans.org/americanism-essay-contest) says essays "will be scored using the following rubric":

| Criterion | Points |
|---|---|
| Topic or theme: does the essay answer the topic question? | 25 |
| Content: original thought | 25 |
| Grammar | 10 |
| Clarity and coherence | 10 |
| Organization: introduction, body, and conclusion | 10 |
| Correct word usage | 10 |
| Word count | 5 |
| Cover sheet | 5 |

That is 100 points. Fifty come from answering the topic and thinking originally. Ten come from following the rules (word count and cover sheet). The decision of the judges is final.

> How can you be a beacon of light for our veterans?
>
> American Legion Auxiliary, Americanism Essay Contest. 500 words. Deadline Essays due from state department chairs to division chairs by April 15; departments (states) set local unit deadlines (no year printed). Source: https://www.alaforveterans.org/americanism-essay-contest (read Nov. 18, 2026)

## Other providers name their criteria


The DAR essay contests say essays are judged "for historical accuracy, organization of materials, interest, originality, spelling, grammar, punctuation, and the quality and scope of references, particularly the use of primary sources." Source: [DAR essay contests](https://www.dar.org/outreach/education/essay-contests).

> Students will be asked to discuss how their chosen Patriot contributed to the founding of the nation.
>
> Daughters of the American Revolution (NSDAR), Patriots of the American Revolution DAR High School Essay Contest. no limit stated. Deadline not stated. Source: https://www.dar.org/outreach/education/essay-contests (read Nov. 18, 2026)

The Elie Wiesel Foundation says: "Each essay will be judged on the quality of the writing along with its integration of ethical concerns and questions of personal and social responsibility." ([Prize in Ethics page](https://eliewieselfoundation.org/prize-in-ethics/).)

Unigo says a panel of judges scores writing ability, creativity, originality and overall excellence, 25 percent each ([Unigo10K rules](https://www.unigo.com/scholarships/our-scholarships/unigo-10k-scholarship)).

The Penn State Schreyer Honors College says: "Reviewers will consider if you answered the full question and how or why you took a specific approach to the question. We are looking for a well-written, well-reasoned, and persuasive response." ([Schreyer first-year page](https://www.shc.psu.edu/admissions/first-year-students).)

The Boren Awards say the essays are "critical to the selection process" ([Boren essays page](https://www.borenawards.org/essays)).

## What the criteria have in common


Across these providers, four things repeat:

1. **Answering the question.** ALA gives it 25 points, and Penn State says reviewers check whether you "answered the full question."
2. **Original thought or originality.** ALA, DAR and Unigo all name it.
3. **Organization and clarity.** ALA and DAR name organization, and ALA adds clarity.
4. **Correct writing.** Grammar and spelling appear at ALA and DAR.

Two providers add something less common: references (DAR) and creativity (Unigo). Rules count too. ALA gives 10 points for word count and cover sheet. Use the [three-pass edit guide](/guides/three-pass-edit/) to check a draft against each criterion.

## Anonymous judging


Some providers hide names. The Elie Wiesel Foundation states, "Submissions are judged anonymously" and tells you to leave off your name, school and identifying references. The University of Alabama Honors College asks that names and contact details stay out of the essay and resume. When a provider judges anonymously, a story still works. Details that identify you directly, such as your school's name, are what to leave out. See [the format rules](/scholarship-essay-format/).

## Interviews follow the essay at some providers


16 prompts in the bank come from providers that say finalists are interviewed. They include NC State, the Paul & Daisy Soros Fellowships, Truman, the University of Alabama and SMU. An interviewer may ask about anything you wrote, so keep a copy and be ready to talk about every detail in it. Boren goes the other way: its essays page says there is no semi-finalist or interview phase, so the essays carry everything. See [scholarship interview questions](/scholarship-interview-questions/).

## Questions this page answers

**Do readers score grammar?** Some do. ALA gives 10 points for grammar, DAR lists spelling, grammar and punctuation. Others do not list it but readers notice.

**Is anonymous judging common?** It is stated by two providers in the bank, Elie Wiesel and the University of Alabama. Most providers say nothing either way.

## Sources

- American Legion Auxiliary Americanism Essay Contest (rubric): https://www.alaforveterans.org/americanism-essay-contest (read 2026-11-18)
- DAR essay contests (judging line, from the Prompt Bank): https://www.dar.org/outreach/education/essay-contests (read 2026-11-18)
- Elie Wiesel Foundation Prize in Ethics: https://eliewieselfoundation.org/prize-in-ethics/ (read 2026-11-18)
- Unigo10K scholarship official rules: https://www.unigo.com/scholarships/our-scholarships/unigo-10k-scholarship (read 2026-11-18)
- Penn State Schreyer Honors College first-year page: https://www.shc.psu.edu/admissions/first-year-students (read 2026-11-18)
- Boren Awards essays page: https://www.borenawards.org/essays (read 2026-11-18)
- University of Alabama Witt fellows application information: https://honors.ua.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/13/2026/09/WFP-Application-Information-Entering-2027.pdf (read 2026-11-18)

Canonical: https://howtowriteascholarshipessay.com/how-scholarship-essays-are-judged/