The prompt
The prompt asks three things: what happened, how it affected you, and what you learned. The writer moved to the United States at sixteen and speaks Portuguese at home. See more challenge prompts and the page for students writing in a second language.
The lessons we take from obstacles we encounter can be fundamental to later success. Recount a time when you faced a challenge, setback, or failure. How did it affect you, and what did you learn from the experience?
The example
Example written for this guide
Why it works, line by line
My first chemistry exam in college came back with a 54.1 I had studied, and most of the material was review for me. I took two years of chemistry in Brazil before my family moved here when I was sixteen. The problem was the English in the questions. I knew how to find a limiting reactant, but I did not know the word "limiting," and on almost every word problem I lost time just working out what it was asking.
01 word 11 of 345
The setback is in the first sentence, with the number.
I was embarrassed, and I did not tell my parents about the grade for a couple of weeks.3 They were proud that I was taking a university chemistry class, and I did not want them to worry. For a while I thought about dropping the class and taking it again when my English was better.
03 word 98 of 345
The prompt asks how it affected you. The writer answers with what they did and almost did (drop the class), which is easier to believe than a list of feelings.
Instead I started a vocabulary notebook just for chemistry. I wrote down every word from the exam, the homework or the lecture slides that I could not explain, with the Portuguese word next to it and an example sentence from the textbook. By the second exam I had a little over a hundred words. I studied them on the bus to campus.
I also started going to office hours, which I had been avoiding because I was nervous about my accent. My professor had me read a question out loud and then explain in my own words what it was asking. I was slow at first, but after a few weeks I could do it without looking anything up.5
05 word 254 of 345
Progress is reported in plain terms, with no claim bigger than the facts.
I got a 79 on the second exam and an 86 on the final. That was not the top of the class, but I finished the final with time left.6
06 word 284 of 345
The result is stated without inflating it.
I learned that I should ask for help earlier, and that a problem I thought was about chemistry was really about reading. Now I start a new vocabulary notebook in the first week of every science class. For organic chemistry next semester, I plan to email the professor in December for the syllabus so I can start the word list early.
Why it works, line by line
- "I knew how to find a limiting reactant, but I did not know the word 'limiting'." One example makes the real problem clear: the language, not the chemistry.
- "I wrote down every word from the exam, the homework or the lecture slides that I could not explain." The fix is described closely enough that a reader could copy it.
- "I learned that I should ask for help earlier." The prompt asks what you learned, so the essay says it in one plain sentence, then ends on a plan for next semester.
What a weaker draft would do
- Open with a quote about failure or a sentence on how obstacles make us stronger. The prompt already says that; repeating it spends words.
- Hide the 54. A setback essay with no real low point gives the reader nothing to measure the recovery against.
- State the lesson in big words over a whole paragraph. One plain sentence answers the question, and a plan for the next class backs it up.
Reusing it
The notebook carries over. For a why this field prompt, the chemistry stays and the language story shrinks to one paragraph; the 86 on the final becomes the start of an interest. For a tell us about yourself prompt, the move at sixteen opens the essay and the notebook becomes one example among two or three. The reuse map shows how the Union Plus and Terry versions of this prompt overlap.
Questions this page answers
- Can I write about a failure that was my fault?
Yes. A failure you caused, followed by what you changed, often reads as more honest than bad luck.
- Should I fix my grammar so it sounds like a native speaker?
Fix errors, then keep your sentences. A reader would rather hear clear, simple English in your voice than borrowed phrases.
Sources
- Union Plus (Union Privilege), Union Plus Scholarship Essay 2 (Option A) read Nov. 18, 2026
Last reviewed Nov. 18, 2026