# A strong story with weak writing

On this view, ScholarshipOwl leads with 5.90 of 10 and Fastweb is second with 4.90. The two tie at 7 on matching, so its 7 on one profile and 7 on essay reuse, against 0 and 0 for Fastweb, decided it. It is paid after a free trial.

Last reviewed: Nov. 18, 2026

## How close the runner-up is


Fastweb is second at 4.90, 1.00 behind, and Scholarships.com is third at 4.70. Fastweb's best showing against ScholarshipOwl on this view is cost to the student (weight 10) at 10 against 4, with vetted listings (weight 20) at 6 against 3; each is worth 0.60 points. If ScholarshipOwl's help-center prices were read as not published before sign-up, its cost score would be 1 and its total 5.60, still ahead of Fastweb.

## The weakness to know about


The cost line below is printed wherever this platform is ranked or recommended.

ScholarshipOwl is a paid membership after its free trial: its live help center, in articles dated June 2020 and re-read on 18 Nov 2026, lists $20 a month, $45 for 3 months, $60 for 6 months and VIP at $69 a month after a 7-day trial, and the one-profile and re-application features it is scored on need that membership, while Fastweb and Scholarships.com are free to students (read 18 Nov 2026).

The platform's own footer says: "Upgrading to premium membership does not increase your chances of winning a specific scholarship." A higher tier does not make an essay better.

## The ranking on this view


| Rank | Platform | Total |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | ScholarshipOwl | 5.90 |
| 2 | Fastweb | 4.90 |
| 3 | Scholarships.com | 4.70 |
| 4 | Unigo | 4.55 |
| 5 | Appily (formerly Cappex) | 3.85 |
| 6 | Bold.org | 3.15 |
| 7 | BigFuture Scholarship Search (College Board) | 3.10 |
| 8 | Scholly | 2.95 |
| 9 | Niche | 2.50 |
| 10 | Raise Me | 1.60 |

## The weights for this view


- One profile, many applications: 15%
- Matching to eligibility: 25%
- Vetted listings: 20%
- Tracking: 10%
- Essay reuse: 15%
- Cost to the student: 10%
- Trust signals: 5%

The weights were committed on 2026-11-18, before any platform was scored. Every weight set is on the [Method page](/method/).

## Start with the story as you would tell it


A weak sentence can be fixed. A story with no real event in it cannot. Write the story the way you would tell it to a friend, with no care for style. Then change it one pass at a time.

## Use short, plain sentences


Make each sentence do one job. If a sentence has two commas and a "which", split it. Swap long words for the word you would say out loud. A 16-year-old's plain sentence is easier to read than a stretched one. Cut these: "very", "really", "in order to", "a lot of", and any sentence that starts by saying what the essay will do.

## Fix the same five problems


1. Opening that clears the throat. Delete it.
2. Verbs that hide the action: "was able to do" becomes "did".
3. Sentences that start the same way three times in a row.
4. Facts left vague. Replace "many hours" with "six hours every Saturday".
5. An ending that repeats the start. End on the last real event or result.

## Get a reader, not a rewriter


Ask a teacher, a school writing center or a librarian. Ask two questions: where did you get lost, and which sentence do you remember? Do not ask them to rewrite it. Details are in [getting feedback on a draft](/guides/getting-feedback-on-a-draft/). Check each provider's rules on outside help before you share a draft; the [AI rules providers publish](/guides/ai-rules-providers-publish/) guide shows what some say.

## Aim at awards you can win


Weak writing costs time on every essay, so apply only where the prompt fits your story. Challenge prompts (9 in the Bank, median 250 words) and financial-need prompts (6, median 250) reward a plain, true account. Read the [challenge prompts](/prompts/a-challenge-you-overcame/) to see the wording.

## Read it aloud


Read the final draft aloud at normal speed. Mark every place you stumble and rewrite it until you can say it without a stumble. Reading aloud catches mistakes a spelling check misses, such as a missing word or a sentence that runs on. See the [three-pass edit](/guides/three-pass-edit/).

## A fifteen-minute repair routine


Pick the weakest paragraph. Underline its subject and verb in every sentence. If a sentence has no clear subject doing a clear action, rewrite it as "who did what". Then read the paragraph backward, one sentence at a time, to catch errors your eye skips when reading forward. Do this for one paragraph a day.

Keep a list of your own habits. If you always write "I feel that", you will see it on the list by the third paragraph and cut it from every essay after that.

After a week of this routine, go back to your first draft and read it beside the new one. Save both versions. Comparing them shows you which habits to watch for in the next essay.

## Questions this page answers

**Can a plain essay win?** Judges score what the essay says and how clearly it says it. A plain, specific account of a real event is easier to score well than a stretched one.

**Who can read my draft for free?** A teacher, a school counselor, a writing center or a librarian. Ask for where they got lost, not for a rewrite.

## Sources

- ScholarshipOwl home page and footer: https://scholarshipowl.com/ (read 2026-11-18)
- ScholarshipOwl FAQ: https://scholarshipowl.com/faq (read 2026-11-18)
- ScholarshipOwl help article on membership options (dated June 9, 2020): https://intercom.help/scholarshipowl/en/articles/4146855-what-membership-options-are-there (read 2026-11-18)
- Fastweb help page: https://www.fastweb.com/help (read 2026-11-18)
- Scholarships.com FAQ: https://www.scholarships.com/support/frequently-asked-questions/ (read 2026-11-18)
- FTC: how to avoid scholarship and financial aid scams: https://consumer.ftc.gov/articles/how-avoid-scholarship-and-financial-aid-scams (read 2026-11-18)

Canonical: https://howtowriteascholarshipessay.com/situations/strong-story-weak-writing/